Thursday, October 29, 2026

That Is The Question


 

40 comments:

  1. Kyle Shanahan on Mike Evans:

    “Hey, there's times you're just going to sit there and wait and Mike will get it done. You don't need to progress even if your feet tell you to. If the coverage doesn't go there, you just wait and give him time because he'll come down with it.'"

    Kyle is absolutely smitten with having a dynamic X receiver.

    Andre Johnson, Julio Jones, Josh Gordon, Mike Evans… and to a lesser degree: Pierre Garçon, Aiyuk.

    I hope the stars align for Kyle to have another stud WR in the near future

    ReplyDelete
  2. AES, does this graph change your mind?

    ReplyDelete
  3. Lowest pressure rate allowed in 1-on-1 pass pro matchups this season, per NextGenStats:

    1. Trent Williams – 3.2%
    2. Amarius Mims – 3.9%
    3. Garett Bolles – 4.7%
    4. Blake Miller – 6.0%
    5. Christian Darrisaw – 6.5%
    6. Colton McKivitz – 6.7%
    7. Kahlil Benson – 6.9%

    > Minimum 100 snaps

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I put it in the great category due to his team first mentality over money. I wish I had 52 more players with that attitude!

      Delete
  4. Mims was a real roll of the dice. Had all the measurables without the body of work. Looks like the Bengals rolled 7 or 11 with that 18th pick. I could see Baalke making that pick. I'm not sure I could have.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Yes, somewhat. Luckily the 49ers have a very good QB that is efficient in running out of the pocket and make big plays. Because, if Purdy didn't have good escapebility, he probably would have been sacked around 10 times right now.
    I ask this question; is Purdy running from the pocket by design, or because of a pocket breakdown?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. He's had time to go through his progressions for the most part. If the receiver is open, he gets the ball out. Evans is always open. Robinson gets open. Purdy isn't perfect, and yes, his elite reactionary quickness and spatial awareness in the pocket mitigates sacks, but generally the sacks come when he's forced to hold onto the football.

      Delete
    2. My comment on this is no indictment in Purdy. It has more to do with pass-pro that causes Purdy to run from the pocket. To be more specific, Colby is the weak link in pass-pro.

      Delete
    3. Razor makes a good point though AES. Purdy hasn't had to make many exits from the pocket due to quick pressures. And not all the quick pressures have been on the OL - there's been quick pressures due to overloads.

      The OL has done a good job in pass pro this year.

      Delete
    4. Razor does make a good point. Perhaps I'm viewing it from a different perspective.

      Delete
    5. I agree with Scooter and Razor. The O line as a whole has been very good in pass pro. My only concern is Colby. He started out playing very well but the last 2 games have not been very good. It could just be a bump in the road but if he continues to play like he has for the last 2 weeks it could be a problem

      Delete
    6. AES, my take is it may just come down to expectations. It is my opinion that an OL, no matter how good, should not be expected to hold up and keep a perfect pocket around the QB consistently for 2.5s or longer down to down against a capable pass rush unit. You'll get some breakdowns, and you'll get some instances of pocket collapsing. What you want to avoid is allowing quick pressures that don't allow the QB time to go through progressions or keep his eyes down the field.

      Purdy, bar a few fairly rare instances, has primarily only "had" to escape the pocket after having time to go through some progressions and see nothing he liked. That's the OL doing it's job well, imo.

      Delete
    7. You and Razor are correct. But, I just failed to explain my perspective the way I needed to.
      It's all good.

      Delete
  6. Interesting note on Lynch's trade proclivities mid-season; He's made 5 with 0 days left at the deadline. 2 with one day left. 2 within a week and 1 twelve days out.

    ReplyDelete
  7. Most QB pressures after facing double team this season, per NextGenStats:

    1. Jeffery Simmons - 10
    2. Dexter Lawrence - 7
    2. Leonard Williams - 7
    2. Cameron Heyward - 7
    2. Zach Allen - 7
    2. Osa Odighizuwa - 7

    Now pencil in Buckner next to OO and Bosa. Should be interesting.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yea, the rotation to keep guys fresh is the best we've had in recent memory.

      Delete
  8. Replies
    1. The Colts Givens and the Colts taketh.

      Delete
    2. 🤣 good one razor!

      Good for Givens - he gets full salary and a chance to play.

      Delete
  9. Christian McCaffrey stats this season and where he ranks among the rest of NFL RBs:

    - Rushing Yds: 389 (18th)
    - YPC: 4.63 (25th)
    - TDs: 8 (T-1st)
    - Recs: 34 (2nd)
    - Receiving Yds: 251 (4th)

    ReplyDelete
  10. NFL players with 0 missed tackles this season (min. 230 snaps)

    49ers CB Deommodore Lenoir
    Saints CB Kool-Aid McKinstry
    Steelers DT Cam Heyward
    Falcons DT Gervon Dexter
    Cowboys DT Kenny Clark
    Saints EDGE Chase Young
    Patriots DT Milton Williams
    Patriots EDGE Elijah Ponder

    ReplyDelete
  11. Question for the blog:
    Should JL trade for another affordable WR?
    WR candidates;
    WR Devaughn Vele, Saints
    WR Josh Downs, Colts
    WR Quentin Johnston, Charfgers
    WR Brian Thomas Jr. Jacksonville
    Note: IMO, Garrett Wilson, isn't "affordable." Not with the 2027 draft loaded with WR's

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It really depends on whether they (a) expect Evans to be fine to play through his Achilles tendinitis and (b) expect to get other WRs that are currently injured back soon.

      If Evans, Deebo, Robinson and Kirk are all fit after the bye, where does a new "affordable" WR fit in? I think in that case any WR they add probably also needs to be a PR/ KR, and take Cowing's spot on the 53.

      But, if they have doubts on Evans, Deebo or Robinson returning any time soon, then yeah, I could see them look to make a move.

      Delete
  12. Scooter
    While I agree with you, my thinking was to limit Evans work load and stress on his Achilles tendon. Save him for games they'll need him to win! (KC, Seattle, Vikings, and playoffs).
    RE Cowing: While I agree, KS has praised Cowing for his explosive plays and progress. So you believe it was just coach speak and the
    9ers will cut him?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Well, you don't replace what Evans provides without adding a true #1 WR. And a true #1 WR isn't "affordable".

      If you want someone to rotate in more so Evans snaps are limited, doesn’t DRob already provide that, when healthy? So if that's what they are looking for, it probably means the player needs to be an obvious upgrade on DRob.

      With Cowing, I'm just saying if they add a WR and then everyone you expect back comes back, any player they add is likely not seeing a lot of snaps at WR (unless it's a high end guy that would be a clear cut top 3 WR on the roster, which may not be "affordable"). In which case, a guy that can also take over Cowing's role when everyone is healthy would seem to make more sense.

      Delete
    2. Scooter
      As you know, Shanahan's offensive requires wide receivers that impact both the passing game and the outside-zone run scheme.
      IMHO, of the WR I listed, Devaughn Vele best fits Shanahan's requirements? At 6'5" X 210, Vele has the size. Shanahan values, a large perimeter block-first WR to seal the edge on outside zone run plays. He also provides a possession target that can navigate the middle of the field, convert on 3rd downs and is a Red Zone target. DRob is a Z/Slot.
      Vele has 33 rec, 348 yds, 3 TDs (7 games), DRob has 5 rec, 84 yds, 1 TD (in 2 games before IR) and 16.8 yards per catch VS Vele's 10.5 yards per catch and he's not on IR.
      Both WR's are reliable depth pieces, but IMO, their physical profiles and usage patterns are different:
      DRob provides playbook versatility and vertical pacing, while
      Vele provides Possession, intermediate boundary and a red zone target.
      Vele has also established a highly dependable weekly floor in N.O., securing at least 3 to 7 receptions in every game he has played this year.oth WR's fits Shanahan's ZBS, IMHO, Vele is a better replacement for Evans than DRob.

      Delete
    3. Wouldn't they be more likely to go for Jennings than Vele? Basically the same type of player. And Jennings would likely be substantially cheaper.

      Delete
    4. Scooter
      Could be? But JJ demanded $20+ Mil to sign, as a WR 3 and IMO, that turned the 9er FO off! Especially when they signed Mike Evans, as a WR 1 all pro, for effectively a one-year deal worth ~$14.3 million for the 2026 season.
      The Saints are paying Devaughn Vele $1,031,120.AAV and
      He consistently sees high snap counts and a regular target share (averaging around 5–6 targets per game), firmly solidifying his role as the team's number two receiver.

      Delete
    5. Jennings is only on around $3M in base salary this year, so salary isn't an issue with Jennings. And draft capital required would likely be a lot less than a guy you correctly outline is currently a starting WR performing well.

      Jennings knows the system. Shanahan loved him. They wanted to keep him. He got greedy, he's paid the price.

      Delete
    6. Scooter
      As you point out, Jennings is making ~$3 Mil Base, as a WR 3.
      and he's seen a limited role in the passing game with the Vikings.
      "He got greedy, he's paid the price." Not sure how much he's still loved. But I agree, he knows the system.

      WR Devaughn Vele, has been heavily used by the Saints in 2026, logging 33 receptions for 348 yards and 3 touchdowns across 7 games. And NO, Devaughn Vele is NOT making more than JJ.Vale's salary for 2026 is $1,075,000. he's been heavily used by the Saints, 2026 season, logging 33 receptions for 348 yards and 3 touchdowns across 7 games.



      Delete
    7. Is Vele even available? Starting WR for a team that is 1 game back from the division lead. Would have to cost a bit to get him.

      Delete
  13. Putting aside the need for a punt returner, what do you think of renting Stefon Diggs if he’s available and affordable. Not an X, but as you say we have DRob for that. Seems like Diggs could become potent. So we’d have
    Evans
    DRob
    Kirk
    Diggs
    Watkins

    Pick your poison.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies

    1. Drat I forgot Deebo.

      Delete
    2. The last thing this team needs is a player that has the potential to disrupt team chemistry. No thanks on Diggs.

      I don't think they'll go for a big name WR. If they go WR, imo it will be someone that will come fairly cheap.

      I think the most likely guy they'd go get is Darnell Mooney. Giants are reportedly shopping him for a late round pick. Spent two years with Morris in ATL.

      For a smoky trade target, they might give old mate Bobby Saleh a call and see if Ridley is available for cheap.

      Delete
  14. Savalas
    RE WR Diggs! I'm with Scooter, NO Thanks!

    Scooter
    RE WR Darrell Mooney, Giants: He's (5'11" X 175! He's had inconsistencies with drop issues in traffic, and varying route precision against physical coverage. Other than that, I agree. He
    fits for KS's system, though he brings a different dimension than a traditional Shanahan power wideout. (M. Evans).
    If the D brings the LB's / S down to the los, Mooney has the acceleration to beat safety help over the top, making him a perfect field-stretcher for KS'a play-action game.

    ReplyDelete
  15. Yeah. Our in-house WRs can get the job done when they are healthy. Deebo and Demarcus could be back soon after the bye. Watkins, Cook, and Kirk could be good plugin players when called on. Key here is staying healthy when they all return.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. AES
      Based on what we've seen the first 7 games, what's the odds of Mike Even, or for that matter, the other WR staying healthy the rest if of the season, including play offs?

      Delete
  16. There is no true non injury players in the league. We're finding that out with vets like Evans, Kirk, Deebo, Demarcus, and with the our young WRs like Stribling and of course Pearsall. I'm not sure which (trade) WR could fill in at a bargain price at the moment. I'd rather roll with the in-house guys for now and keep my fingers crossed that they stay healthy.

    ReplyDelete

Sunday Night Football Week 10: Vikings vs 49ers

Home away from home as I'm told the ratio of 49ers fans to Vikings fans is 90/10 here in Mexico City tonight. We've got the game of ...